Sunday, 29 December 2013

Street Harassment and The Informal Ghettoization of Women - Cynthia Grant Bowmen

“Özgürlüğün en temel anlamı yani qısıtlanmadan özgürlük (freedom from restraint) esas alındığında aslında qadınların özgürlüğü xiyabanda taciz ile qısıtlanır. Çünkü qadınların fiziksel ve coğrafik hareketliliklerini sınırlayır ve qamusal alanda yalnız olaraq tezahürlerini engelleyir. Bu anlamda, xiyabanda taciz qadınların enformal getolaşdırmalarını – özel alanın aile ocağına getolaşdırma- başarmış olur” (Bowman, 1993, s. 520).   
 








* Street harassment is a phenomenon that has not generally been viewed by academics, judges, or legislators as a problem requiring legal redress, either because these mostly male observers have not noticed the behavior or because they have considered it trivial and thus not within the proper scope of the law. (p.519) 

* The liberty of women, in this most fundamental sense of freedom from restraint, is substantially limited by street harassment, which reduces their physical and geo- graphical mobility and often prevents them from appearing alone in public places.12 In this sense, street harassment accomplishes an in- formal ghettoization of women - a ghettoization to the private sphere of hearth and home.  (p.520)

Toward a Working Definition of Street Harassment

* Although street harassment encompasses a wide variety of behaviors, gestures, and comments, it has some defining characteristics: (i) the targets of street harassment are female;31 (2) the harassers are male; (3) the harassers are unacquainted with their targets; (4) the encouniter is face to face; (5) the forum is a public one, such as a street, sidewalk, bus, bus station, taxi, or other place to which the public generally has access;32 but (6) the content of the speech, if any, is not intended as public discourse. (p. 523-524)

* Central to the freedom to be at ease in public spaces is the capacity to pass through them while retaining a certain zone of privacy and autonomy - a zone of interpersonal distance that is crossed only by mutual consent. If, by contrast, women are subject to violation of that zone of personal privacy when they enter public areas, that very invasion of privacy effectively drives women back into the private sphere, where they may avoid such violations. Thus, by turning women into objects of public attention when they are in public, harassers drive home the message that women belong only in the world of the private.  (p: 526 – 527) 

* The target of street harassment is literally every woman between the age when her body begins to develop sexually and that undefined point when she is no longer assumed to be a sexual being because she is "too old." Different women may experience street harassment in different ways, though. For a very young girl, it is one of her first lessons in what it means to be a sexual being - a confusing and shame-producing experience. (P: 531) 

The experience of street harassment may also differ with the race, class, or ethnicity of the targeted woman and the history of gender interactions to which she has become accustomed.  

The Consequences of Street Harassment for Women, Gender, and Society 

* The fear, psychological trauma, and restrictions on personal liberty described above have obvious consequences for women as individuals. Not so obvious, perhaps, are the consequences suffered by society as a whole. In fact, the harms of street harassment extend to its impact upon the relationship between the sexes, upon the construction of gender in our society, and upon social and political relationships in general. (P:540)

* street harassment both increases women's dependence on men and contributes to distrust and hostility between the sexes. 

* Second, contrary to the folk wisdom that "sticks and stones may break my bones but words will never hurt me," language is instru- mental in the construction of reality; language locates individuals within that reality and thus constructs their gender identities.Women learn to associate their bodies with shame, fear, and humili- ation.115 Women also learn their place in society from language, and they learn that this place is not a public one. The remarks women hear from harassers on the street carry the implicit (and sometimes explicit) message that women do not belong in public, where they draw attention by their mere appearance, but rather in the private sphere, at home.(p.541)

qaynaq: The Harvard Law Review (1993), vol. 106, N. 3, pp: 517-580

   
 
 
 

No comments:

Post a Comment